Had an amazing experience at Pellegrino & Son’s for dinner! It was our first time visiting and the food was delicious. You can tell they use high quality ingredients and that they care very much about their customers. We were treated so kindly. The owner himself took our order and gave us recommendations! The vodka sauce was amazing! As well as the chicken Caesar salad and the pizza slices we got. Saved this place to come back every time we’re in the area!

-Migdalis O.

I went in to get a pizza I ordered for pick up on 2/24/23 I was greeted by the cashier and the owner!! Very pleasant and after paying for the pizza, I mentioned about the Philly Cheesesteaks. (being from South Philly).. the owner offered to make a Philly Cheese for me.. that jawn was so good! Not everyone can make a Philly Cheesesteak but, this one hit the spot! S/O to the amazing staff and the owner. Very friendly and welcoming! You don’t see that in most establishments nowadays. Thank you so much and will be paying it forward for someone very soon!

-Imanni C

If you're a fan of Sicilian slices or bar pie, this spot offers an exceptional thin Sicilian slice that outshines every other option in Middletown. Despite living 30 minutes away, I willingly pass by several pizza places to savor a pie here. The combination of a thin, crispy crust and a semi-sweet, robust sauce sets it apart. Additionally, the staff's kindness towards adults with disabilities makes this place stand out in a society where such attention is often overlooked.

-John C